Monday, June 29, 2009
2009 Preseason Ramblings
Lookin Good:
Vernon Davis may be back on the radar this year. As usual his impressive physique and athletic ability is impressing coaches in OTAs. I remain skeptical that he can maintain the mental discipline necessary to perform at a high level all season. After drafting him in the first round, I dropped him at the end of last season after three fruitless years waiting for some production. If you have space on your roster and need a big upside risk then stash him now.
Rashard Mendenhall hasn't had a lot of coverage in OTAs, but neither has any other runner in the Steel City. I fully expect a timeshare this year, and that Mendenhall will take over fulltime duties next year when Willie Parker is released due to his age and high cost.
Chris Wells is really looking good to me at this point. He will see a ton of work this year in the Cardinal backfield and should be more than up to the task. He has a great mix of balance, power and vision which will fit nicely with the running game Arizona is trying to promote. He is my top RB out of this years rookie class.
Stumbling:
Joaquin Iglesias was a hot topic after the draft, but coaches recent comments that he is viewed strictly as a slot option leaves me feeling tepid on his long term value. I wouldn't take him before round 4 in rookie drafts, but he is a solid value at that level.
Jason Campbell does not seem to have much job security in Washington. He has not been granted an extension, and has Colt Brennan nipping at his heels. I am not a Brennan fan, but it's tough to ignore all the chatter coming out of DC this offseason which is touting Brennan as a viable option to replace Campbell (as early as mid season). I think Campbell is very solid QB who is being forced to play in a system which does not suit his talents. It would not surprise me if he was let go by the Redskins and picked up by another team looking for a solid QB play next year (Vikings once Favre quits again?).
Wednesday, November 12, 2008
QB Values
1. Drew Brees, NO, Age: 29
Brees has been getting it done even with sub par talent at WR for the last 5 weeks. He is on pace to go over 4,000 yards this season and now he has Colston back. Brees is set for the foreseeable future to continue his domination.
2. Jay Cutler, DEN, Age: 25
He has really come on this season and has phenomenal rapport with his main man: Brandon Marshall. With the emergence of Eddie Royal in the WR2 position and Tony Scheffler at TE, Cutler has a full compliment of weapons.
3. Peyton Manning, IND, Age: 32
Harrison is back at least for this season, and Manning is back in his groove. When he is playing at his best nobody can touch him....unfortunately he isn't always playing his best these days.
4. Tony Romo, DAL, Age: 28
Currently has the best compliment of weapons around him of any QB in the league, and with the addition of Roy Williams it only gets stronger.
5. Tom Brady, NE, Age: 31
He'll be back next season and being a strong pocket passer shouldn't suffer too much from his knee surgery. The knee may limit his mobility a bit, but he should still have Moss and Welker to throw to so he should get back in stride quickly.
Strong Starters:
6. Aaron Rodgers, GB, Age: 24
Jennings has emerged as one of the leagues top receivers, and Driver has a few good years left in him. Rodgers has been playing tough, and playing well. He is young and poised for a long successful career.
7. Ben Roethlisberger, PIT, Age: 26
Big Ben has a solid team around him and although he doesn't always have the gaudiest numbers he is quite consistent.
8. Philip Rivers, SD, Age: 26
Rivers has a solid running game to keep the pressure off him, and has been throwing the ball very well this season. He has enough weapons around him to keep his numbers up.
Shaky Starters:
9. Donovan Mcnabb, PHL, Age: 31
Mcnabb is throwing to a second rate receiving core, but at least the emergence of Desean Jackson has given him one legit target to throw to. Mcnabb is playing at a very high level right now, but Westbrooks constant injuries couple with Mcnabb's history of injuries makes him a shaky starter to rely on.
10. Kurt Warner, ARI, Age: 37
Warner is an anomaly. He is really pushing the age envelope but still playing incredibly well. He is shaky because of his age and long term status - he will be playing as a top 5 QB for at least the rest of this year. While this makes him hard to rank, I'm putting him here and trusting that people will take his age into account when drafting or trading for him. Contenders buy, builders sell.
11. Matt Schaub, HOU, Age: 27
12. Eli Manning, NYG, Age: 27
Let me start by saying that I am not an Eli Manning fan. I think he makes too many mental mistakes, and he will certainly never be as good as his big brother. With that said, the lesser manning will be throwing to Plaxico Burress for a few years and has decent value if you can get over his multiple INT performances every now and then.
13. Matt Ryan, ATL, Age: 23
Ryan doesn't look, act or play like a rookie. He has poise and makes all of the plays he needs to. There is a ton of upside, and if he can continue his consistent climb he will be top 10 soon enough.
14. David Garrard, JAX, Age: 30
Garrard doesnt have a lot of up or downside. He is a pretty consistent QB who is not prone to mistakes or INT's. He will get you consistent points but never win seasons for you.
Strong Backups:
15. Jason Campbell, WAS, Age: 26
I would like to rank Campbell higher, because I think he has a great skill set and can be a top QB in the NFL. Unfortunately he has been forced to learn too many different offenses recently and it may be showing through in his inconsistent play. Once I see some more consistency I will push him up.
16. Trent Edwards, BUF, Age: 25
17. Carson Palmer, CIN, Age: 29
Palmer didn't look very good before his elbow injury, and his elbow injury doesn't look good in and of itself. Chad Johnson may be on the decline and there is no running game to speak of for the Bengals right now or for the foreseeable future.
Shaky Backups:
18. Brady Quinn, CLE, Age: 23
19. Jake Delhomme, CAR, Age: 33
Delhomme is looking to have recovered nicely from his surgery. Steve Smith is still tearing secondaries to shreds and Delhomme is doing a great job of getting him the ball. With Jonathan Stewart and DeAngelo Williams as a two headed backfield monster keeping pressure off of him Delhomme should have a nice year.
20. Joe Flacco, BAL, Age: 22
21. Matt Hasselbeck, SEA, Age: 33
Lacking WRs and a solid line, Hasselbeck is having a rough season. He is 33 and I don't see much future upside for him.
22. Kyle Orton, CHI, Age: 25
Hes making throws all over the field to his motley WR crew. There is a lot of risk here, but at this point in the rankings he is a solid buy.
Stash Em:
23. Marc Bulger, STL, Age: 31
The Rams are awful this year, and will need to do some major rebuilding in the offseason. If they do manage to get something going on offense next year Bulger still has tools in Holt and the rookie Avery he can utilize.
24. Vince Young, TEN, Age: 25
Even when he was starting Young wasn't really getting it done on the field. Hopefully he will work out whatever issues he had before he goes back in. His upside is pretty low in fantasy terms, as he has never been a fantasy stud.
25. Jamarcus Russell, OAK, Age: 23
Big arm, big contract, small results. Russell has not developed as rapidly as the Raiders may have hoped. He has a ways to go before we can tell if he will be a startable fantasy QB.
26. Brett Favre, NYJ, Age: 39
Favre is giving it a hell of a go this year. He will give you a chance at a huge game every week and is a great play if you don't have a solid starter. He is ranked this low because of the obvious impending retirement.
Huge job security concerns with Quinn pushing to play. If Anderson can keep getting long completions to Braylon Edwards and remain on top of his game he has a chance to put up nice numbers.
28. Matt Leinart
29. Drew Stanton
Longshots:
30. Chad Pennington: I don't see him as a long term solution in miami, but he is playing pretty well right now. Rank him up in the lower 20's if you need a starting QB to throw in your lineup but don't expect anything after this year.
31. Sage Rosenfels
32. Kevin Kolb
33. Tarvaris Jackson
34. J.P. Losman
35. Chad Henne
The Good, the bad and the ugly
Saturday, November 8, 2008
Week 10 Pump and Dump
Maurice Jones Drew: So MJD has been inconsistent this year.....who cares? This week he gets to tee off on the Lions defense and their abysmal defensive line. Everyone has run roughshod over the lions so far, and even the tattered jaguars offensive line should be able to open up a few holes for pocket hercules.
Forecast: 20 carries, 100 yards, 2 TDs
Chad Pennington: Pennington is playing better than you probably think he is. He has been very efficient through the air, even though he fails to stretch the field effectively at times. When teams take away his deep option by double covering Ginn, he is able to feast on the short routes that are opened up for his man crush Camarillo. Seattle couldn't cover a cupcake if the entire defense consisted of fat kids. They are going to be decimated by the fins weak armed signal caller.
Forecast: 22 of 30, 285 yards, 1 TD
Chris Johnson: Woohoo I get to hype Johnson again. This week he is facing the Bears, a usually formidable adversary. There is no stopping Johnson though, and he will put up starter numbers this week again. Johnson is too fast to contain even when defenses have put a linebacker or two as spys on him all game. The Titans new involvement of Johnson in the receiving game coupled with Jeff Fishers declaration that they will find new ways to get him the ball is all the green light I need.
Forecast: 20 carries, 80 yards, 6 receptions, 38 yards, 1 TD
DUMPS:
Matt Forte: It seems like Forte is a golden boy in most analysts eyes. I'm not sure why his pedestrian 3.8 YPC average (and thats including his 5.7 YPC day against the terrible Lions) inspires their awe. Forte is an average runner and above average receiver who is on team that has been heavily featuring him so far. The Bears will not have room to run against the Titans, and thats all there is to it. If you play forte you are hoping for a big receiving day from him....don't expect anything more.
Forecast: 20 carries, 47 yards, 5 receptions, 20 yards, 0 TD's
Marques Colston: With talk that he may not even be starting for the Saints anymore Colston's outlook for the week (and possibly near future) are bleak. Until he gets back into a groove with Brees, I would avoid playing him.
Forecast: 4 receptions, 35 yards, 0 TDs
Ryan Grant: At this point I almost feel like I'm picking on Grant, but lets face the facts: Ryan Grant can only run the ball up the middle. The Vikings are built to stop runs up the middle. 1 + 1 = 0 yards for Grant this weekend. Bench him.
Forecast: 15 carries, 42 yards, 0 TDs
Willis McGahee: With the Ravens unable to commit to any of their backs as the "starter", we are left to guess at which backs will carry the day. After Rice's performance last week I don't think we will be seeing McGahee featured heavily this week. Although the matchup isn't bad, I would stay away until we see how everything plays out.
Forecast: 5 carries, 25 yards, 0 TDs
Tuesday, November 4, 2008
The Good, the bad and the ugly
PUMPS: 9-4 (69% wins)
Friday, October 31, 2008
Week 9 Pump and Dump
PUMP:
Aaron Rodgers: If you don't pay attention to matchups this might seem like an obvious call. However Rodgers is facing the ferocious TEN defense this week. Although it may seem tempting to bench him, I would keep him in your lineups. Although last week was really the only time TEN has given up TDs through the air - there is now a blueprint for GB to use. It also helps that GB is coming off a bye which has hopefully helped Rodgers heal a bit.
Forecast: 25 of 35, 250 yards, 2 TDs, 1 INT
Jerricho Cottchery: Here is my vote for playing the "who gets to abuse Terrence Mcgee" game. Cottchery draws him in coverage this weekend. Mcgee is still injured and will not be able to cover him. It does not matter that Favre will throw some bad balls, because all you need out of Cottchery is one good bomb reception.
Forecast: 7 receptions, 100 yards, 1 TD
Michael Turner: If you have had Turner riding your bench the past couple weeks I don't blame you, but its time to roll out the Burner this weekend. He is facing a suspect OAK defense and he has absolutely dominted the weak defenses he has come up against this season. After the inevitably impressive performance this weekend he should get a bump in trade value (something to keep in mind if you are trying to move him).
Forecast: 20 carries, 110 yards, 1 TD
Trent Edwards: Edwards should be Trentlicious going up against a bad Jets secondary. Last week they were torched by Tyler Thigpen, and there is no doubt that Edwards is a significantly better QB. Play Edwards as a QB1 this weekend with confidence.
Forecast: 20 of 30, 280 yards, 2 TDs, 0 INTs
DUMP:
Ryan Grant: Ryan Grant hasn't looked very good this season. He has been hesitant and has not hit the holes with authority. TEN will make sure that his season remains miserable this weekend. Although there isnt really any good point to attack the Titans defense through, the straight ahead ground game of Grant is probably the worst.
Forecast: 15 carries, 50 yards, 1 rec., 5 yards, 0 TDs
Jospeh Addai: Hamstring issues, general offensive synergy issues, Rhodes stealing carries.....there are a lot of reasons to sit Addai this weekend. Take your pick.
Forecast: 12 carries, 45 yards, 0 TDs
Dwayne Bowe: This is a scarily bad matchup for Bowe. The TB defense has made a mockery of some pretty decent QB's this year, and Tyler Thigpen is a joke. Because the TB corners play 'over' coverage most of the time, Bowe will have some short receptions. I expect his overall day to be pretty anemic however.
Forecast: 4 receptions, 35 yards, 0 TDs
Tony Scheffler: Scheffler's status is still up in the air for sunday. Don't wait around for his 4:15 start, as I expect that even if he does play he will be a bit limited by his groin injury.
Forecast: 3 receptions, 40 yards, 0 TDs